Superior long-term creep resistance of a 10% Cr steel


Creep is a time dependent effect of external forces in relation to mechanical properties of materials. Creep-resistant martensitic steels with an average of about 10% chromium have been found to be suitable materials for making turbine components of fossil fuel plants. Specifically, their alloys are tailored to provide stability to the tempered martensite lath structure (TMLS) which comprises prior austenite grains, blocks, packets and laths with a high dislocation density in the lath interiors under creep conditions. Previous studies have shown that TMLS is the main factor in the superior creep strength of these steels during long-term creep. Regardless, researchers have acknowledged that the instability of TMLS under creep reduces the creep strength and yields to the creep strength breakdown. Two processes promote the onset of creep strength breakdown: a knitting reaction and sub-grain coarsening. Unfortunately, the role that the microstructural changes in the long-term creep behavior and superior creep resistance without creep strength breakdown up to an extremely long rupture time for these 10% chromium steels has not been investigated in sufficient detail.

To this note, a team of three researchers led by professor Rustam Kaibyshev from the Belgorod State University in Russia proposed a study whose main objective was to elucidate the origin of the elimination of creep strength breakdown up to 4·104 h at 650 °C under long-term creep with an applied stress of 120 MPa in this steel. They purposed to pay specific attention to the effect of the dispersion of the secondary phases on the stability of the tempered martensite lath structure. Their work is currently published in the research journal, Materials Science & Engineering A.

The material scientists here commenced their research work by studying the creep behavior and evolution of lathe martensite structure and precipitates during creep. Next, they analyzed various microstructural factors that affect the superior creep resistance including: homogeneously distributed M(C,N) carbonitrides, alloying by (W+Mo) elements and particles of M23C6 and Laves phases.

The authors observed that the tempered martensite lath structure of the 10% chromium steel remained stable during long-term creep testing until rupture. Again, they noted that during transient creep, the Laves phase particles precipitated in an analogous manner as that during long-term aging. It was also revealed that nanoscale M23C6 carbides and M(C,N) carbonitrides could compensate for the negative effects of W depletion from the solid solution and extensive coarsening of the Laves phase particles; this would result in superior long-term creep resistance.

The Roman Mishnev and colleagues study has demonstrated the creep behavior and evolution of lath structure and precipitates under an applied stress of 120 MPa for the 10% Cr steel with Cobalt, increased Boron and decreased Nitrogen. It has been seen that the M23C6 carbides demonstrate a high coarsening resistance under creep conditions and exert a high Zener drag pressure before rupture because of the coherency of their interfaces. Altogether, the strain-induced transformation of a portion of the precipitated V-rich M(C,N) carbonitrides to the Z-phase does not affect the creep strength because the Z-phase particles are nanoscale and negligible in quantity.


superior long-term creep resistance of a 10% Cr steel. Advances in Engineering



About the author

Roman Mishnev is a PhD student, Research Associate in the Laboratory for Mechanical Properties of Nanostructured Materials and Superalloys at Belgorod National Research University, Russia, since 2013 when he received his Engineer Diploma. His research interests are concerned with investigation of advanced heat-resistant high-chromium martensitic steels. His research is focused on creep and fatigue properties, impact toughness, microstructure, fractography, precipitates, transmission and scanning electron microscopy. His presentation on the long-term microstructural evolution in a 10%Cr high creep resistant martensitic steel at the International Conference on Advances in Materials Technology for Fossil Power Plants which was organized by the Electric Power Research Institute in 2016 was recognized as the best presentation. In 2017, he was awarded by Gold medal from Russian Academy of Science.

About the author

Nadezhda Dudova is a Leading Research Associate in the Laboratory for Mechanical Properties of Nanostructured Materials and Superalloys at Belgorod National Research University, Russia, since 2008. In 1999 she received her Engineer Diploma from Ufa State Aviation Technical University and, in 2009 she received her PhD degree in the field of Condensed Matter Physics from the Institute for Metals Superplasticity Problems. She is author of about 50 scientific papers. She has experience in the deformation behavior and formation of ultrafine and nanocrystalline structure in nickel-based alloys under severe plastic deformation. Her current research interests include mechanisms of microstructural changes under creep and fatigue conditions in high-chromium martensitic steels. Her major focus is on alloying of advanced high-chromium steels, heat treatment, mechanical characterization, creep and low-cycle fatigue, impact toughness, microstructure, phase transformation, dispersed precipitates.

About the author

Rustam Kaibyshev is a Head of the Laboratory for Mechanical Properties of Nanostructured Materials and Superalloys at Belgorod National Research University, Russia, since 2007. He received his PhD degree in the field of Metal Science and Heat Treatment in 1991 and DrSci degree in the field of Condensed Matter Physics in 1995 from Moscow Institute for Steel and Alloys.
He is author of more than 400 papers. He is a member of Organizing Committees of several International Conferences, e.g., ICSAM, REX&GG, THERMEC, ICAA, ECCC. In 2018, he was awarded by “Professor of Year”, National Prize from Russian Professors’ Convention. Research interests include wide range of materials such as metal matrix composite, martensitic and austenitic heat-resistant steels, aluminum, nickel and copper alloys. His scientific expertise incorporates creep and superplasticity mechanisms, dynamic recrystallization, microstructural design, evolution of ultrafine grains during severe plastic deformation, mechanisms of plastic deformation.


R. Mishnev, N. Dudova, R. Kaibyshev. On the origin of the superior long-term creep resistance of a 10% Cr steel. Materials Science & Engineering A, volume 713 (2018) pages 161–173

Go To Materials Science & Engineering

Check Also

Smart magnetic force coupled flexible acoustic emission sensor